Guide · The Waterproof Company
Torch-on or liquid rubber: which suits a Gauteng roof?
If you have asked for roof waterproofing quotes in Pretoria or Johannesburg, you have probably been offered torch-on, liquid rubber, or both. They are the two most common systems on Gauteng roofs, and both can do a good job. They are not interchangeable, though. This guide explains how they differ and how a site inspection decides between them.
Request a quoteThe two systems
What torch-on is
Torch-on is a waterproofing membrane made from bitumen that has been modified with polymers, on a reinforcing carrier, and supplied in rolls about a metre wide. The installer primes the roof, unrolls the membrane and heats the underside with a gas torch until it melts and bonds to the surface. Each roll overlaps the one next to it, and the overlap (the lap) is heat-welded closed.
Some torch-on systems are a single layer; others use an underlay plus a cap sheet. Exposed torch-on is usually protected from the sun by a reflective coating or a mineral-chip surface. On a concrete slab, a well-installed torch-on system with sound laps and upstands is a robust, widely used solution.
What liquid rubber is
“Liquid rubber” is a catch-all name for liquid-applied membranes. They are brushed, rolled or sprayed on in two or more coats, usually with a reinforcing fabric bedded into the first coat at joints, cracks and corners. When the coats cure, they form one continuous membrane without laps.
There are several families. Water-based acrylics are common on roofs and are usually finished with a UV-resistant topcoat. Bitumen-based emulsions, some of them rubber-modified, are often used where the membrane will be covered. Polyurethane systems are tougher and more elastic, and some are designed for foot traffic. Cementitious coatings are used more below ground and in wet areas than on roofs.
Where each fits
Where torch-on tends to suit
Torch-on is at its best on concrete slabs and flat roofs with large, simple areas, where rolls can be laid in long, straight runs with consistent laps. It is commonly used on parapet roofs, slabs over garages and extensions, and to line box gutters behind parapets.
Because it arrives as a factory-made sheet, its thickness is consistent across the roof. That is a real advantage on big, open areas where a liquid would need careful control of how much is applied.
Where liquid rubber tends to suit
Liquid systems shine where a sheet would need a lot of cutting and patching: roofs crowded with pipes, geyser supports, air-conditioning brackets and solar mounts; small balconies and roof decks; outlets in awkward places; and junctions between different materials.
They are also the usual choice on metal roofs. On IBR, Chromadek and corrugated sheeting, leaks tend to come from side laps, end laps and fixings. A liquid system with reinforcement over those points can seal them, whereas heat is not usually appropriate on thin metal. The same goes for anywhere an open flame would be a risk, for example next to timber, some insulation, or certain existing coatings.
Gauteng conditions
How the Highveld climate affects the choice
Gauteng roofs face three things in particular. First, heavy summer thunderstorms, roughly October to March, that put a lot of water on a roof in a short time, sometimes with hail. Second, strong sun at altitude, which degrades unprotected bitumen and some coatings. Third, a dry winter with large swings between hot days and cold nights, which makes membranes and the slab underneath expand and contract every day.
Both systems can cope with these conditions when properly specified and installed. What matters most is that exposed bitumen is protected from UV, that liquid systems are applied at the thickness the manufacturer specifies, and that the details (outlets, upstands and laps) are done well enough to survive a storm that fills the roof faster than it drains.
The weather also affects timing. Torch-on can be installed in cooler weather but needs a dry surface. Liquid systems need dry conditions until each coat has cured. In the summer rains, both are planned around the forecast, which is one reason the dry months are the best time to waterproof.
What is already there
The existing roof often decides it
Very few roofs are bare. Most already have an old membrane, a coating, or several layers of both. Before recommending anything, an installer should check whether the existing layer is well bonded and dry underneath, and whether the new product is compatible with it.
Torch-on can sometimes go over an old torch-on membrane that is sound. Some liquid systems can go over old bitumen or acrylic after preparation; others cannot. If the existing layer is blistered, cracked through, lifting or holding water, it generally has to come off. Covering a failed system usually just hides the problem until the next storm.
Sometimes the answer is both
It is common to use torch-on across the open field of a concrete roof and a liquid system at the awkward details: around clusters of pipes, at a complicated outlet or where the roof meets a timber structure. As long as the two products are compatible and the junction between them is detailed properly, this combines the strengths of each.
Comparing quotes
What to look for in a quote
Whichever system is proposed, a good quote should name the product, say how many layers or coats will be applied, describe the preparation (cleaning, removing loose material, crack repairs, priming), and explain how outlets, upstands, laps and penetrations will be finished. It should say whether a reflective or UV topcoat is part of the system, what is excluded, and what guarantee, if any, applies and on what terms.
Be cautious of a quote that only gives a price per square metre and a product name. Two quotes for “torch-on” can describe very different jobs.
How an inspection decides
In practice, the choice comes down to the substrate (concrete, metal, an existing membrane), the shape and details of the roof, how the roof is used, access, and whether heat is safe. Those are things to judge on site, not from a photo. If you would like advice on your own roof, see our page on roof waterproofing, which covers both systems and the details that make them last.
Next steps
Read more about roof waterproofing, or if you are in the capital, about waterproofing in Pretoria. When you are ready, request a quote.
Request a waterproofing quote
Send your suburb, what is leaking and a few photos. We arrange a site visit and set out the work in a written quote.
Request a quote